Queen Latifah was the most popular guess on the air - but the answer's actually MISS PIGGY!
I chose this question today after reading that Jim Henson's original plans for the Muppets are up for bid. They include a new character called Piggy Lee, who would later become known as Miss Piggy. Nate D. Sanders Auctions estimate that the handwritten pitch and drawings will go for as much as $40,000.
Colin got the answer this morning with a little help from his girlfriend Emily - we see a romantic trip to Nantucket in their future, helped along by a $30 gift card to the Steamship Authority. We're pretty sure Kermit would approve!